Wednesday, February 4, 2009

Driving, Cycling and Walking in Japan



What is it about driving in Japan that is so different from driving in Australia?
How has this difference come about and what can we learn from it?

In a word RESPECT !
And is seated in the Japanese’s people nature …. An almost Zen like respect for one another

Driving in Japan is mostly in urban environments which on first inspection are extremely busy comprising very narrow and complexes streetscapes having usually many people walking and cycling, often without separation such as foot paths from other vehicles.
From a transport point of view not the place where you would expect to find patients and respect for other road users.

A speed limit of 40kph and all this complexity serves to slow down traffic but it would loose its congenial atmosphere quickly without the all important respect for one another.
This social attitude, personal commitment and understanding that cars being larger and potentially more dangerous give way to walkers and cyclist make for a very user friendly road environment.

After spending time in Japan and cycling thousands of kilometers you come to the realization that excess space in road design and urban layout leads to excess speed of vehicles and large empty lifeless spaces which makes for an undesirable urban environment.
Too much space and speed leads to the ‘isolation’ of people, particularly the young and old.
Japan not afflicted with excess space in there urban layout has many people of all ages walking and cycling everywhere, in big cities towns and villages. The roads are quite and non threatening compared to our high speed race tracks in Australia and don’t require segregated duplication of the existing roads ways to cycle safely. Even walkers co habit many roadways with the cars carefully negotiating their way around young and old… Amazing, you just have to experience it first hand for a real understanding how we have such an inhumane urban transport system.

A classic example of our almost ingrained inability to share space and respect other can be seen in the ubiquitous Australia shopping mall which completely bans cycling, presumably for the reason that cycling and walking don’t mix. Worlds away, a typical shopping street in Japan which would have a similar or denser pedestrian ratio is just the place where millions of people interact walking and cycling every day. You will be amazed at first when you find yourself riding inside what feels like a shopping mall with many walkers and allsorts of other cyclist, business man, students, housewives with children and groceries on board… Everyone just ‘blends’ and doesn’t resent the other being there or considers their journey more important.
AC BC CITIES

One theory on the lack of cycling as a preferred way to get around can be understood by looking at ‘New’ AC cities and ‘Old’ BC cities…
Cities built BC (Before Cars) generally are considered more livable due to the layout being built on a human scale, narrow streets only wide enough for the passage of people and carts now serve to limit the speed, use and necessity of cars thus making favorable environments for walking, cycling and public transport.
Cities built AC (After Cars) were built understandably for cars, not appreciating the long term effects on livability, pollution, noise, energy consumption, accidents, health and social costs and also the detrimental effects on public transport etc.

The three countries with the highest energy use, Australia, Canada and America are also mostly comprised of AC cities and associated urban design.
In these newly occupied countries there was little precedence of BC cities or towns with hundreds if not thousands of years of human scale evolution. So, urban design has spread fueled buy the availability of seemingly limitless land and carbon to make it all work.

The over use of space is also reflected in the history of design of vehicles built by these nations. Typically large over powered vehicles when compared to the typical smaller cars of BC environments found in Europe and Japan. The down sizing of AC nation’s car designs is a reaction to economy rather than the necessity or understanding for vehicles to fit into, rather than dominate urban landscapes.

Very seldom in Japan you hear a car accelerate with its full ability like just about every car does from the lights in Australia. It just doesn’t require it. There is always a lot going on in the streets of dense urban environments, caution and respect for other streetscape users is so naturally ingrained aggressive driving is just not done. When the lights turn green there is often an uncanny pause then a slow glide off the mark.

The top speed and acceleration ability of current vehicles is a very useless and misguided product of 'testosterone fueled marketing', particularly ridiculous in this time of reducing carbon output.
This is the time to legislate mechanical and electronic acceleration and speed limits on all vehicles.
Why should we have to worry about exceeding the speed limits when it can be controlled for us. And why should we have the ability to pointlessly use up fuel trying to out run the traffic only to be stopped at the next lights?
Such limits on acceleration and top speed are already a product of ‘self limited’ denser urban area such as in Japan. Now there is an opportunity to both reduce CO2 output and charm traffic for a more livable Australian streetscape.


Eco City Building


Mandatory Speed and Acceleration Rates


The idea of introducing Mandatory Speed and Acceleration Rates for private motor vehicles is intended to help address Global Warming Transport issues, help in the implementation of sustainable urban design and reduce vehicle accidents and associated social and health costs.

Implementing Mandatory Speed and Acceleration Rates legislation is unique in that it doesn’t require a complete renewal of the current motor vehicle fleet. Thus being timely and saving energy till sustainable transport can be realized.
Electronic and mechanical equipment such as GPS or other speed sign transmitting devices, mechanical limiters and engine management program adjustments already exists to achieve this and could be installed or retro fitted to a large proportion of the motor vehicle fleet. New vehicle design could be required by legislation to incorporate these changes during manufacture.

Rationalizing Vehicle Design

Important aspects of car design have been led by market forces, which cater to our desire amongst other things to enjoy speed. This situation has produced a primitive attitude to vehicle development meant for transportation.
Vehicle design led by the ploy of motor sport and a lack of foresight regarding emissions and safety has led to ‘over designed’ vehicles for the task at hand, but alas, understandable from a male dominated industry.
Just look at the majority of car advertising as an indication of the current mind set that the car is an expression of a person’s unlimited power regardless of realty.

Vehicles that fail to consider our ability to control speed have serious safety issues. The justification for lack of appropriate limits is that we have posted speed limits to control maximum speed.
It is evident that the majority of drivers exceed these speed limits. And excessive speed is a factor in many accidents particularly involving fatalities.
In most places in Australia, if you drive at the posted speed limit you will have several cars behind you wanting to go faster. 10kph over the posted limit is considered by many drivers necessary to get to their destinations regardless of available time.

Why should we as drivers have to worry about controlling our speed, or worry about other drivers ability to control speed when it can be set for us?
If maximum speed limits are considered necessary why do we have vehicles that can exceed them? The question has been asked many times and has been just surged off.
Until now it has been considered a right if not a status symbol to buy as much horsepower and maximum speed as we can afford.

Market forces in vehicle design have been allowed to put cars on our roads that should be on a race track. This is not just the sports car sector of car production, but also the family car is over powered for safety and environmental considerations.

Production of cars that are not governed for speed and power should be tolerated, but only allowed to be used at Motor Sport facilities allowing them to be used at their full potential in a controlled environment. In the least, we owe this to the vehicle designers, a consumer of such vehicles should demand it, but most importantly it is a safer and a more appropriate place for the enjoyment of speed than our public roads.

The Good News
As rates of vehicle emissions and fossil fuel consumption are becoming important the arguments for speed control can be applied to acceleration rates. The good news is that controlling maximum speed and acceleration also controls vehicles consumption and carbon emissions.

Justification for applying Mandatory Speed and Acceleration Rates can be considered in 2 areas

Environmental Benefits

Limiting Atmospheric Carbon Output
Lots of energy is consumed by a vehicle in the acceleration phase of a journey. The faster that acceleration, the more fuel is used to achieve basically the same result.
Human nature ensures that a lot of energy is wasted accelerating, faster than necessary, to the next set of traffic lights, only to do it over again.
This is compounded with car designers competing with each other over performance statistics to capture market share,

Energy and emissions can be saved by setting the acceleration rate of all vehicles to at least half the current average. Currently there is no limit on the rate of acceleration other than the driver’s ability to pay for the fuel and the car ability to consume it. There are some discretionary registration and tax incentives to curb large vehicles but this is not enough. All current vehicles regardless of the capacity are wasting fuel if they are accelerated and driven at today’s typical speeds.

Slowing oil consumption
Peak Oil is eventually going to be reached and efforts should be made to curb the unnecessary consumption of Fossil Fuels now.
It could be considered as a defensive position with regard to Transport Global Warming issues.

While the search for sustainable transport gains momentum, it would be remiss to not adopt available technologies and legislation that can limit outputs from carbon emitting vehicles.

Social Benefits

Reducing Motor Vehicle Accidents
A reduction in current speed limits of 25% across all speed zones coupled with taking away a drivers ability to exceed those limits will have a drastic effect on vehicles accidents injuries.

Reducing Aggressive and Dangerous Driving
If all cars could only accelerate and travel at the same reduced speed aggressive and dangerous driving will be reduced. Pedestrians, cyclist, children and older drivers will feel less intimidated by the speed of traffic than in the current situation.

Reducing Speed Limits
Reducing Speed Limits by 25% across all speed zones is possible if we take the ability to disregard these speed limits from the driver.
It will save carbon emissions as well as reduce road accident trauma and associated social and health costs. The down side to slower speed limits cannot outweigh these benefits.

Improved Urban Amenity
Slower speed limits and acceleration control will allow for a denser, human friendly urban design. Communities can claim back the streetscape for more appropriate uses such as cycling and walking. Speed control will reduce effective vehicle commuter distance which will impair urban sprawl, in turn reducing energy consumption and emissions.

Allow parity with Public Transport.
Slower vehicle speeds will allow public transport travel times to compete with car travel, which will increase the use of public transport and reduces emissions and vehicular accidents further.

Legislation has changed public perceptions in the past when such changes were considered unnecessary or too burdensome, such as limiting the right to smoke tobacco in public confined spaces, or the right to bare arms, in which the motive was public safety.
The effects of putting these limits on motor vehicles are not onerous considering the necessity of curbing carbon emissions and the social benefits.

If advertising is any indications of the current mind set that the car is an expression of a person’s unlimited power regardless of realty we are in for a challenge.
Surly with all the benefits of motorized transport we have gained the time and experience to slow down a little.

Get the F--K out of my way!!




Generally speaking, Japanese drivers don’t drive fast, posted speed limits are 40kph in urban areas and many country and mountian roads. Japanese drivers are very reactionary, ready to stop or give way when required. Most drivers’s cycle or have cycled in the very same urban environment…
Nowadays with sports cycling becoming popular even on mountain roads motorist are not traumatized being held up by a cyclist. Although drivers often pass very closely they do so at relatively slow speed and there is often a pause along side while they establish there presence then they will proceed.
The same could be said about cycling in Japanese cities on foot paths and the many narrow streets with shared environments for cars, bikes and walkers, young and old.

Cycling in less dense, larger streetscapes of Western AC cities (After Car), traffic speed is much higher and I feel drivers are often not as reactionary or have little cycling knowledge, and even I might suggest are often too ‘self centered’ for a congenial cohabitation.

Cyclist here go with the flow and are respectful of there place in the scheme of things. One quickly learns not to wonder of course without looking for cyclist or traffic. Speed is generally reasonable ans suited to stopping as the complexity demands.
The art is to blend and give way without resentment or self righteousness.
I look at the lack of bell ringing although sometimes necessary, as also something to be used with respect for others serenity…Unlike other placesin the world where we tend to think with a self-centered egoistic attitude.

I would like to make another point about ‘transport culture’…I am often aware of what seams like an almost Buddhist philosophy to Japanese transport on trains, on bikes, cars or walking, that of respect for others. I see it in the cleanliness and order of public transport as well in the cooperative and congenial way that people walk, cycle and drive together.

Maybe its our own attitude that need adjusting to a different way of thinking albeit ‘getting around’. We are the foreigners here, question your own perspectives also…I’m just saying...

All that being said I acknowledge that stupid thing happen like riding without lights, drunk etc
But with such close cooperation and attention that is required in Japanese streetscapes even these stupidities are accommodated without the egoist descriptive and angst that less tolerant people so quickly dispatch.